Rainbow and Patriarchy

topic posted Wed, September 9, 2009 - 5:03 PM by  UGG
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
Your thoughts and experiences? Is the rainbow family patriarchal?
It's been my experience that rainbow fosters a culture of (albeit loose) gender roles where women are healers and men are warriors. There's even a well known chant that says "we honor you we empower you to be who you are" and then goes on to reinforce those gender roles. As a man I've been told quite a few times by several different individuals that "its our job to protect the mommas." What does this say about rainbow? Are "the mommas" incapable of taking care of themselves (and if so, why?), or are we creating a culture of sexism by spreading these type of thoughts among rainbow men?

I'd also like to ask about homophobia. Of course we all know that everyone has a belly button and all family is welcome and I never seen any blatant examples of homophobic activities at a gathering. It's been my perception, however, that most folks prefer fairy camp to stay at fairy camp. I sense an unspoken distrust among people who will visit every other camp in the woods and avoid fairy. Its something I've been guilty of in the past, but I'd like to work on. Has anyone else noticed this or am I way off track there?

I'm not attempting to be accusatory and point a finger at any person or group of people. This thread is not meant to be an arena for throwing stones. I'd simply like to hear other people's opinions on the matter. I'd like to know if there are things that we can do as a movement to eliminate patriarchy from rainbow culture. As a straight male I understand that I have a limited perspective of this issue and so I would really like to hear from my female, trans, and queer family.
posted by:
UGG
offline UGG
Missouri
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: Rainbow and Patriarchy

    Thu, September 10, 2009 - 5:49 PM
    Funny you mention all this. If you asked me a year ago, I would have thought we were less sexist than average, but then I posed the question and got reamed in a lot of rainbow circles by men who thought I was full of it - that's when the hostility towards women started to fly.

    I think it's very complicated and don't have a lot of answers. But in New Mexico this year we had a "Warrior Women's Council" that went for 6 hours, was very well attended and was very productive.

    I camped near Fairy Camp this year and found the people hanging there were a mixed bag - lots of straight people hanging out. As a friend of mine pointed out when I posed the questions in Spring 2008, we're trying to mesh what we call "tribal culture" with modern culture.

    Personally I do a lot of Shanti Sena and work mostly with a bunch of other strong women - although there are men as well.

    I'm glad you brought this up as the more we ponder these things, the easier equality becomes.
    • Re: Rainbow and Patriarchy

      Fri, September 11, 2009 - 3:02 AM
      Just posing a question. Would it be sexist if there was a " Warrior Men's Council" that excluded women and was just for men ?
      • Re: Rainbow and Patriarchy

        Fri, September 11, 2009 - 10:09 AM
        Men weren't excluded, they were there but as listeners only. But no, I don't think so. We've had grandmother's councils where everyone was welcome to sit and listen but only grandmother's can speak (and the same with grandfathers).
        • Re: Rainbow and Patriarchy

          Sun, September 13, 2009 - 7:46 PM
          i just think exclusive camps/conversations are generally not that awesome, isn't rainbow all about like"hey! it's just all of us in here trying to make things happen!!" i just dont see a reason to put an emphasis on why one type is more welcome, or why the words of this or that particular genre of human are more of less important and necessary to be heard. i know i have a slight feeling of not being wanted at sister camp just cus i got a ding ding and it kind of hurts my feelings...i just want the we love you thing to be really real and open, and i want everyone to feel it and mean it, i know it's a tall order but in my mind it seems like it should be pretty easy, doesnt it seem like it should be the easiest thing?
          love cole
    • Re: Rainbow and Patriarchy

      Tue, December 1, 2009 - 5:15 PM
      "Funny you mention all this. If you asked me a year ago, I would have thought we were less sexist than average, but then I posed the question and got reamed in a lot of rainbow circles by men who thought I was full of it - that's when the hostility towards women started to fly."

      Welcome to the world of hypocrisy sister.

      The issue is *the* single biggest reason I no longer go to gatherings. I was able to brush off a few anomalous encounters and situations but found it increasingly difficult to deal with what I believe is a creeping, insidious, patriarchal mindset much like the one you describe.

      Another experience has been that often enough the most vocal and adamant protestations have come from those individuals who tend to exhibit the most patriarchal/chauvinistic/misogynistic tendencies.

      On the flip side of that coin have been the women who *insist* that such behaviors and attitudes will never change so long as these menfolk remain clueless and in the dark and that it is somehow *my* responsibility to teach them. There was a time I might have bought into that belief system with a high degree of sincerity.

      But those days are long past and very much behind me. The turnabout started right around the time I came to understand that the simplistic warrior(m)/healer(w)-protector(m)/teacher(w) dichotomy was just more oversimplified sociological pablum that continually is fed to those not wanting (or willing) to ask what they're eating to feed their souls.

      It isn't my responsibility to actively teach anyone. That's bullshit. It suggests yet another traditional role that's expected of women in both our and other cultures. The responsibility lies with the ones who are deficient or lazy in their interactions with all people and of all genders and of all cultures.

      I'll sit down now.
      • Re: Rainbow and Patriarchy

        Tue, December 1, 2009 - 8:08 PM
        You had to taunt and tease me into responding. You are right, the world is becoming Matriarchal, but change is very slow. We need the feminine side to lead the world away from warlike activities and into a nurturing world. Those who hold onto the patriarchal ideals, both men and women, are most likely afraid of change and resist releasing their grip on control. It will take time but it will come to fruition, so don't get disillusioned. Those that hang onto the patriarchal ideals believe they are just as right as the matriarchal believe they are right. I don't think people can be swayed into changing their beliefs, but that through attrition, change will happen. I believe this is in the hands of the Creator.
        • Re: Rainbow and Patriarchy

          Tue, December 1, 2009 - 9:32 PM
          My intent was never to taunt nor was it to tease.

          My intent was only to speak my truth.
          • Re: Rainbow and Patriarchy

            Wed, December 2, 2009 - 7:18 AM
            That was said in jest, but I had been wanting to put my two cents worth in. I never intended to say one group would control another, but that is the way many think. If one was to relinquish control over another or group of people. Would that person become controlled by someone else. Not so, but the person with the controlling point of view would think that they could become subject of someone else's controlling efforts. There is the crux of the problem, each persons point of view differs to such a degree that they will fight till death to protect their point of view, it becomes less of an issue about who is right or wrong, but more so an effort to protect each individuals way of thinking. We have each person standing alone ready to fight to defend the way they believe. Just look at people in politics to see what I mean. The new way of thinking is for everyone to think as one unit. The Universal concept of Oneness comes into play, everyone joins into thinking in a new way, as one group. There would be give or take to accommodate everyone, no more infighting, everyone joins hands and become one with all there is. That is the way to truth, love and happiness.
  • Re: Rainbow and Patriarchy

    Sat, September 12, 2009 - 9:26 AM
    For change to happen on the grander scale, I believe it first needs to happen within each & every one of us as individuals. And I don't doubt that it's happening already, otherwise this thread probably wouldn't have been started. Myself, I've also experienced "gender roles" at rainbow gatherings, councils, potlucks. What we all need to remember, though, is that there is no rulebook. I know I never received a copy of what was required of me as a male! "We honor you we empower you to be who you are". So why aren't we??? Speaking just from my own perspective, I sometimes feel that certain folks have some sort of fear/unknowing of being their own person. It's almost like being in high school & trying your absolute hardest to fit in with the "in-crowd" in order to gain acceptance. Again, speaking from my own perspective, I vowed a long time ago...even before experiencing rainbow...to follow the beat of my own drum. I mean, isn't it that same inner drumbeat that lead many of us to rainbow in the first place? The views/opinions of others are not always necessarily our own. Empowerment happens when we stand up & express & embody what's truly in our hearts rather than the skewed values that are sometimes thrown at us. In this way, we are able to gain acceptance of OURSELVES, which is what truly matters. I am a male. I am a warrior AND a healer. I embrace my ENTIRE family...the sisters, the brothers, the children, the trees, the four leggeds, the winged ones, Mother Earth, Father Sky & the Great Spirit. I am a perpetual student & don't pretend to have all the answers. My mission is, simply, one of service to all. I'm sure...to some degree...we will always have trials & tribulations to balance out the peace & bliss. And that's ok. In the end, it's the love that matters. And I love you all!!!
  • Re: Rainbow and Patriarchy

    Sun, September 13, 2009 - 2:27 AM
    I have never experienced any freedom limitations based on gender at the RAinbow. I've been going for 10 years. I wouldn't call it patriarchal, rather sensible. Mothers do need to be let to food and services first. Elderly women also ned to be let ahead first, becasue, as proven, omen have more age related problems than men.Sure, then we are talking about elders, and they should always be respected( men too). But I think that part depends more on the condition of the person, and their personal perception of their age.The rest of the line, guys and girls are equal. As far as protection is concerned- I think women wouldn't feel too offended if a guy offered them such. Or at least shouldn't. Playing abadass in the night in a forest is rather silly. Women are generally smaller and easier to abuse.
    On the other hand, why do people not want to acknowledge the fact that men and women are indeed different, and perfect as they are? Look at our matriarchal past- men were still running the heavy weight task. Yes, the true amazons( btw one of the tribes lived in area nowadays known as Azerbaijan, and kicked Pompeii's army' ass) could fight, but still lived with men for reproduction and heavy house choirs. Not because women can't bear weight( I beat up boys in school, I know) but because nature gave us different skills to deal with things. I personally love to be " momma" and feel protected and taken care of, so I can be more relaxed and take care of my children better. Nowadays, after all the " emancipation" all woman ended up with is more choirs to do, more pants to wash( now also their own) ; while men became confused about their roles and responsibilities and turned feminine. As a result, men fail as men, women fail as women.There was and is nothing wrong with gender roles, as long as they are not being forced( like women belongs in the kitchen, or only men drive bullcrap). We have to look deeper into history( or at least listen to AMMA once talking on masculinity and femininity). I like my men old fashioned, and I like to be a bit needy woman. Really. I'm tired of doing everything alone. But all the men I meet nowadays believe in equality. Which leaves me to open my own doors and put on a coat while I have nerve damage in my arm, or carry heavy boxes to the new home after a C-section. The old tribal societies still have peace, because they recognize the strength and weaknesses of either gender.Women rule the house, men- outside. Women need more energy to reproduce and nurture- thus we need more rest from stress. No matter how one fools themselves, women are still mothers, and men- hunters. Any different, would be from nature's point of view, considered deviation from norm (caused by childhood experiences, hormone deficiency and trauma).However, we as humans ,have learned to accept all things unusual, as long as they are not destructive. And its good that way! We should be allowed personal choices: sexual orientation, etc. But many men who believe in equality, are being plain lazy and rude to women nowadays. No concern about the baby crying at her lap, or monthly hormonal shift. Womem seem to have pushed the issue of equal rights to the point men think they should take care of everything alone. Men eave their families easier nowadays too, certain the woman can manage breastfeeding and working full time too! Yes, of course we can and are doing it for most part, bu its destructive to our health, and ability to be mothers and wives( any sex drive lost lately?). All I see in "equal" relationships are overly stressed women.Machismo, on the other hand, completely shuts off what the woman actually wants, but acts as it thinks is good for the woman. SO, you can end up with overworked woman who only takes care of the kids and household, which would seem to give her time for herself- but she has no chance to do what she wants with that time. Or that a man assumes if there's money in the house, he doesn't have to talk to his wife, ask how her day was, do the shoppings, clean his own mess, or be gentle.
    Of course, there are enlightened exceptions in every culture. Like are happy Moslim wife without damaged hips from bending over all day for housework, and who can communicate with their man; or stay home Western mom, so she can enjoy drawing and playing with her kids, instead of the state employees doing it while she's stuck in the next rush hour jam.
    I find modern "Western man" to be useless. And "Eastern man" to be chauvinistic and sexist. Humans need to find balance and harmony still. So, please, keep at least the Rainbow time that time a woman can relax a bit and feel taken care of. My Rainbow sisters and I truly appreciate it( most of us a single moms). Just show respect, we are not pudding.
    As far as Fairy camp- I love hanging out there with all my straight friends, and see no homophobia. Actually, I had more feeling that "fairies" prefer to gather there together, since they could meet a date. Its cute.
  • Re: Rainbow and Patriarchy

    Sun, September 13, 2009 - 7:12 PM
    the fairy thing just comes down to the individual, on the whole i think we the family are very accepting but there will always be that modicum of that fear at gatherings until the rest of the big world is rinsed of it too. as for the protector thing i see where you come from but for me even from when i was a little boy ive always had an instict to protect women or anyone physically smaller or less capable of protecting themselves for that matter...but really when we where in caves, seeing as how it is the woman that would lactate, the dudes just kind of had to watch after, and take care of needs and dangers while the women nurtured, it's primodial, way way deep in there, we are still animals...maybe it is this animal nature we are trying to bring our selves away from so we can evolve?? it's deep in me and i cant feel bad or strange about it, and either way protecting is not dictating or being patriarchal its protecting...thats it. i think... if you feel it, be it, do it, all protectors are good.
    love cole
    • Re: Rainbow and Patriarchy

      Sun, November 29, 2009 - 6:46 PM
      Is the rainbow family feminizing to men?
      • Re: Rainbow and Patriarchy

        Sun, November 29, 2009 - 7:05 PM
        I feel like we are living in a feminized society where what is positively masculine is being erased to create more docile slave people.
        Females afraid of their femininity are suffering from gender pathology and so are homosexuals.
        Let's all try and raise a good family by performing the duties of the roles the creator gave us!
        The creator gave us gender, it's existence 101 in my opinion, so know the creator through your opposite.
        Know yourself and your creator! But don't just believe me! Figure it out yourself! But what might help is...
        Everyone should learn MORE about the 7 hermetic princibles of existence.

        Don't forget we are LIVING IN A MATRIARCHY! WHO DO YOU THINK THE QUEEN OF ENGLAND IS?? And also this is the age of KALI!

        Go ahead and follow me in trying to understand overstand and innerstand gender better with Phil Valentine who is bringing his own tribal fruit to bear in Western Kemet.

        He gets DEEP and DIRTY in gender roles!
        www.youtube.com/view_play_list
        And he comes up with the GOLD
        • Re: Rainbow and Patriarchy

          Tue, December 1, 2009 - 2:33 PM
          I've scene alot of hype just to what is exactly is the rainbow connection.I still believe it was to be exactly how the moment was when it evolved back in Colorodo 30 some years ago.What its become today is socially behavior what everyone thinks what its suppose to be or lack of.Like woodstock,the rainbow gatherings are a moment not a movement
  • Re: Rainbow and Patriarchy

    Wed, December 2, 2009 - 12:16 AM
    There are many roles to play at a gathering a mother , a father, a child. From the perspective of those controlled and the controlling you ask who is in charge the boys or the girls .nobodies in charge dude, just be!
    • Re: Rainbow and Patriarchy

      Sat, December 5, 2009 - 10:38 AM
      To suggest that "rainbow is" patriarchal or matriarchal would be defining rainbow as a whole when i believe its a sum of completely independent parts in that regard. I have met racists, homophobes..ect at rainbow. Ive also met healers, amazingly talented individuals and those who dedicate their lives to serving others. I believe its all apart of the rainbow. Not sure why you would spend any time on this sort of thing. I guess im just not concerned with trying to break it down and analyze it, rather experience it. Rainbow to me is about being in that moment, expecting nothing and experiencing the gathering one moment to the next. Spirit guides, spirit provides..or something like that.
      • nurture

        Tue, December 8, 2009 - 9:47 AM
        i love that last comment, (among many others also)

        "To suggest that "rainbow is" patriarchal or matriarchal would be defining rainbow as a whole when i believe its a sum of completely independent parts"

        we see what we want to see, what we're ready to see, some see healers, others see dealers, and AS IF we could see it all, as if we always tried to see things in the light,

        when we define something, we limit it, to say someone is gay/fairy is to say that that person defines their world through their sexual preference, and it's all down hill from there, because sex is the smallest part of us like all things,
        to say that we don't go to gatherings anymore because of "this and that", is to give-up on a whole, when the holistic parts are what matters, it's to choose one thing and see everything through that, when there's a million things going on,
        The fact is many rainbows (myself included) are still learning, that we always will be, that everyone has been miseducated, bamboozled, and few really know how to think about things without getting over sensitive and totally egoic, like the world revolved around them, around their small, unexamined ideas. If anyone can call us on our collective day-glo shit it's me, because I'm that messed up and high holy, until I realize it's not about everyone else, it's about me, and how I accept or deny things, about how I share or just assume, how I care or just makes absurd demands on reality, then it was no one else, but me and all my shit, it's bigger then rainbow (rainbow just an idea everyone tailors to fit them, like all ideas and some people are obese in the mind) and my lost boy search for utopia, which is never there, but always here, which wasn't emotional, or logical, but rather spiritual, and spirit never gave a fuck about people high ideas and taking sides, because there was nothing but mistaken identity, just one with many mask
        I say bold, loud and clear, "Love on" don't give up, give everyone some time, cut them some slack, hang out with the circles that empower you, don't judge others, because if you give them some love and space, they'll come around and who knows they might become a cornerstone, they might surprise you if you never judge them too quick, and even if some people just get sidetracked on the sidewalk and shit, love it up, forgive, accept them, they've had the worse teachers, hard lives, the crappiest examples, maybe if they had your opportunities they could be all high and holy and pimp, maybe they wouldn't have wasted them again and again like you do, maybe they woulda never taken it for granted, anything, would've just counted blessing and smiles, because that's all that matters,
        There is no patriarchy, matriarchy, black, blue, white, gay, smart, dumb, know again "There is only one tribe" and many parts of it, it might look like different colors or higher or lower vibrations to you, but it's the same, you just haven't taken enough dmt, sang enough heart songs, tried hard enough to accept, to see things through god, as god, we're all one, often dumb and self absorbed, love it, evolve, show others you're not that same kib from a broken home, heart, vision, reunite the tribes with the one love and you will see all the forever innocent and brilliant spectrum, show us love grows like grand verdant and healthy ecosystems, that we are more then they ever imagined, not so petty and self absorbed, show your sister and brother how to rise above or shut up, stop with lame B&W critics when you have so much more to work on in some ways,

        or maybe I'm talking to myself, perhaps you've got it all figured out,

        there is spirit.
        then there's you and mundane patterns,
        rainbow never stops for me, and like HOME above, it's about being in the moment,
        everyone's too serious, getting caught up in exterior designs, rather then the fundamentals, from such a perspective we're all doomed, fact is most hippie, rainbows and anyone isn't logical, rather expect what they want, not just accept what they need, what is everywhere, what is real, which is nothing, which is something, which is comedy, which is compassion, which is overrated and hard to interpret and easy to misunderstand until we overstand it's not about us, that it's about US, so simple, right,
        keep coming to rainbow, keep growing and expanding, things at lower levels won't bother you at higher levels, play the game, taste the rainbow, it's all magic, it never stops, keep coming to rainbow and see it's not about others being a certain way, but about ourselves just being, blame others or just yourself and laugh as you mastermind another disaster and misunderstanding,

        all love and respective
  • Re: Rainbow and Patriarchy

    Yesterday, 6:51 PM
    Woah, kinda disgusted just reading this, what I mean is people are people. There are minor physical differences between men and women. Not too many neurological differences either. Whats the big deal. I'm planning on heading to Nationals this year. And I've only been to one other Rainbow (it was regional) but the impression I gathered is 'Family' is just that. Yes, due to the nature of life and the mentality that is instilled upon us a birth. There is a degree of sexism everywhere. It starts with the kids. Protect the Mommas. Well buddy. I can protect myself, especially if this 'mommas' cookin. Skillets to the head hurt. Its the kids that need protection, that we have to shape and mold into what we want the future to be. Yea, great ideals lets do it ourselves. Well...the simple fact of the matter is. 50 years down the road, their running the show not us.

    If your 'family' it shouldn't matter your race, sexuality, or gender. In my mind. I don't care what the person next to me thinks or not, but in my mind you leave all that when you go home. It would be lovely to bundle it all up and carry it with me always. I try to be a nonjudgmental person, but there are times I find myself slipping. We all have a heart and a brain, and are capabilie of compassion and hatred. But the beauty of 'family' once again...I tend to live in my own little world!! Is that none of that matters when your around the fire.

    Fairy's should stay at FairyCamp...well heck, what makes me wanna throw this computer through a window is that deal that its 100% cool for two women to kiss, but not for two men to kiss. BULLSHIT! Its like I just said programming. Our parents did it to us, with help from the media, were conditioned to have closed minds. Its when your able to break through the BS and realize the beauty of humanity that you've got something.

    *hugs*
    Kitty.

Recent topics in "The Rainbow Family Tribe"